| Year | Winner | 1st Runner-Up | 2nd Runner-Up | 3rd Runner-up |
| 2000 | Jeff and Matt Hardy | Edge and Christian | Buh-Buh Ray and
D-Von Dudley | Kronik |
| 1999 | Kane and X-Pac | Jeff and Matt
Hardy | Buh-Buh Ray and
D-Von Dudley | Booker T and
Stevie Ray |
| 1998 | Billy Gunn and Jesse
James | Sabu and Rob Van
Dam | Kane and Mankind | Kane and
Undertaker |
| 1997 | Scott Hall and Kevin
Nash | Rick and Scott
Steiner | Hawk and Animal | Lex Luger and The
Giant |
| 1996 | Booker T and Stevie
Ray | John Kronus and
Perry Saturn | Rick and Scott Steiner | New Jack and
Mustapha Saed |
| 1995 | Booker T and Stevie
Ray | Bart and Billy Gunn | Owen Hart and
Yokozuna | Rick and Scott
Steiner |
| 1994 | Brian Knobs and Jerry
Sags | Samu and Fatu | Rocco Rock and
Johnny Grunge | Robert Gibson and
Ricky Morton |
| 1993 | Rick and Scott Steiner | Steve Austin and
Brian Pillman | Ted DiBiase and Irwin
R. Schyster | Tom Pritchard and
Stan Lane |
| 1992 | Terry Gordy and Steve
Williams | Earthquake and
Typhoon | Rick and Scott Steiner | Barry Windham
and Dustin Rhodes |
| 1991 | Larry Zbyszko and Arn
Anderson | Hawk and Animal | Rick and Scott Steiner | Robert Fuller and
Jeff Jarrett |
| 1990 | Rick and Scott Steiner | Ax and Smash | Ron Simmons and
Butch Reed | Hawk and Animal |
| 1989 | Tully Blanchard and Arn
Anderson | Ax and Smash | Hawk and Animal | Michael Hayes and
Jimmy Garvin |
| 1988 | Hawk and Animal | Bobby Eaton and
Stan Lane | Ax and Smash | Tully Blanchard
and Arn Anderson |
| 1987 | Bobby Eaton and Stan
Lane | Bret Hart and Jim
Neidhart | Hawk and Animal | Robert Gibson and
Ricky Morton |
| 1986 | Robert Gibson and
Ricky Morton | Hawk and Animal | Davey Boy Smith and
Dynamite Kid | Shawn Michaels
and Marty Jannetty |
| 1985 | Hawk and Animal | Ted DiBiase and
Steve Williams | Ivan and Nikita Koloff | Davey Boy Smith
and Dynamite Kid |
| 1984 | Hawk and Animal | Kerry, Kevin, and
Mike Von Erich | Stan Lane and Steve
Keirn | Robert Gibson and
Ricky Morton |
| 1983 | Hawk and Animal | Kerry, Kevin and
David Von Erich | Michael Hayes, Terry
Gordy, and Buddy
Roberts | Jack and Jerry
Brisco |
| 1982 | Greg Gange and Jim
Brunzell | Mr. Fuji and Mr.
Saito | Michael Hayes and
Terry Gordy | Ole Anderson and
Stan Hansen |
| 1981 | Michael Hayes and
Terry Gordy | Rick Martel and
Tony Garea | Mr. Fuji and Mr. Saito | Greg Gagne and
Jim Brunzell |
| 1980 | Jimmy Snuka and Ray
Stevens | Mr. Wrestling and
Mr. Wrestling II | Afa and Sika | Verne Gagne and
Mad Dog Vachon |
| 1979 | Ivan Putski and Tito
Santana | Jerry and Johnny
Valiant | Paul Jones and Baron
Von Raschke | The Spoiler and
Mark Lewin |
| 1978 | Rick Steamboat and
Paul Jones | The Yukon
Lumberjacks | Mike Graham and
Steve Keirn | Greg Gagne and
Jim Brunzell |
| 1977 | Gene and Ole Anderson | Mr. Fuji and Prof.
Tanaka | Greg Gagne and Jim
Brunzell | Ric Flair and Greg
Valentine |
| 1976 | The Executioners (John
Studd and Killer
Kowalski) | Gene and Ole
Anderson | Billy White Wolf and
Chief Jay Strongbow | Jimmy and Johnny
Valiant |
| 1975 | Gene and Ole Anderson | | | |
| 1974 | Jimmy and Johnny
Valiant | | | |
| 1973 | Nick Bockwinkle and
Ray Stevens | | | |
| 1972 | Dick the Bruiser and
Crusher Lisowski | | | |
