Case Study 'Jatropha Curcas' Africa

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

0.0 Content

.......................................................................................................................... 2

0.1 Abbreviations

............................................................................................................... 3

1. Description of the plant, distribution, ecology

..................................................... 4

1.1 Botanical description.................................................................................................... 4
1.2 Distribution................................................................................................................... 5
1.3 Ecology......................................................................................................................... 6

2. Description of the Jatropha System

........................................................................ 6

2.1 The Jatropha System .................................................................................................... 6
2.2 Possible Uses of the Jatropha Plant.............................................................................. 6

3. Jatropha promotion in selected countries

............................................................. 7

3.0 Benin ............................................................................................................................ 7
3.1 Egypt ............................................................................................................................ 7
3.2 Ethiopia ........................................................................................................................ 7
3.3 Ghana ........................................................................................................................... 7
3.4 Guinea (Conakry) ......................................................................................................... 7
3.5 Madagascar................................................................................................................... 7
3.6 Mali .............................................................................................................................. 7
3.7 Mozambique................................................................................................................. 8
3.8 Namibia ........................................................................................................................ 9
3.9 Senegal ......................................................................................................................... 9
3.10 South Africa ............................................................................................................... 9
3.11 Sudan .......................................................................................................................... 9
3.12 Tanzania ................................................................................................................... 10
3.13 Uganda ..................................................................................................................... 12
3.14 Zambia...................................................................................................................... 13
3.15 Zimbabwe................................................................................................................. 13

4. Impacts of the promotion of the use of Jatropha

............................................... 14

4.1 Social impacts ............................................................................................................ 14
4.2 Ecological impacts ..................................................................................................... 16
4.3 Economic impacts ...................................................................................................... 17

5. Critical assessment of the Jatropha System, based on findings

.................. 24

Soap production: .............................................................................................................. 24
Jatropha oil as fuel: .......................................................................................................... 25
Jatropha plantations:......................................................................................................... 25
Gender Aspects: ............................................................................................................... 25

6. Bibliography

................................................................................................................. 27

7. Attachments:

................................................................................................................ 27

Annex 1 - ToR of Jatropha Case Study

................................................................. 28

Annex 2 - Jatropha in Ghana

.................................................................................... 30

Annex 3 - BUN Zimbabwe

....................................................................................... 32

Annex 4 - Environment Africa

................................................................................. 34

Annex 5 - Jatropha KwaZulu-Natal

........................................................................ 36

Annex 6 - Wiemer, Summary of Economic Analysis

........................................ 37

Annex 7 - Economic analysis of soap production in Tanzania

........................ 39

Annex 8 - Economy of Jatropha utilization in Zambia

...................................... 40

Annex 9 - Wasteland rehabilitation

........................................................................ 43

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 10 - The role of Jatropha in of Carbon sequestration

........................... 44

Annex 11 - Small scale farms with Jatropha hedges in Mozambique

........... 45

Annex 12 - Agricultural Calendar of Mali

............................................................ 46

Annex 13 - Enterprise of Trust – Title page

......................................................... 47

Annex 14 - Paper for Public Field Day in KwaZulu/Natal

............................... 48

0.1 Abbreviations

ARI-Monduli

Alternative resources of income for Monduli women

ATI

Appropriate Technology International, an US American NGO

BftW

Bread for the World

BUN

Biomass

Users

Network

CNESOLER

Centre National d’Energie Solaire et des Energies Renouvelables,

Bamako, Mali

DAEA

Department of Agriculture and Environmental Affairs, South

Africa

DED

German

Development

Service

DMA

Division

Machinisme

Agricole

ELCT

Evangelical Lutheren Church of Tanzania

GTZ

German Agency for Technological Co-operation

JCL

In English language used abbreviation of

Jatropha curcas L.

KAKUTE

Private firm in Arusha, Tanzania, to disseminate Jatropa

KZA

KwaZulu-Natal

MFP

Multi

Functional

Platform

OSCA

Owen Sithole Agricultural College, Empageni, KZA, SA

POPA

Plant Oil Producers Association, Zimbabwe

South

Africa

SUDERETA

Sustainable Development through Renewable Energies in Tanzania

TZS

Tanzanian

Shillings

UNDP

United Nations Development Programme

UNIDO

United Nations Industrial Development Organisation

USD

United

States

Dollar

ZMK

Zambian

Kwacha

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

1. Description of the plant, distribution, ecology

Jatropha curcas L. or physic nut, is a bush or small tree (up to 5 m hight) and belongs to the
euphorbia family. The genus Jatropha contains approximately 170 known species. The genus
name Jatropha derives from the Greek

jatrós

(doctor),

trophé

(food), which implies medicinal

uses. Curcas is the common name for physic nut in Malabar, India.

The plant is planted as a hedge (living fence) by farmers all over the world, because it is not
browsed by animals

About 1 1/2 year old plant in test

plantation, KwaZulu-Natal, South

Africa

35 year old Jatropha trees in Falan,

Mali

Jatroph hedge in Mto Wa Mbu,

Tanzania

1.1 Botanical description

Inflorescence containing male and female flowers

Jatropha curcas L., or physic nut, has thick glabrous branchlets. The tree has a straight trunk
and gray or reddish bark, masked by large white patches. It has green leaves with a length and
width of 6 to 15 cm, with 5 to 7 shallow lobes. The leaves are arranged alternately.

Dormancy is induced by fluctuations in rainfall and temperature/light. But not all trees
respond simultainously. In a hedge you may have branches without leaves, and besides ones
full of green leaves.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

The branches contain a whitish latex, which causes brown stains, which are very difficult to
remove.

Normally, five roots are formed from seeds: one tap root and 4 lateral roots. Plants from
cuttings develop only lateral roots.

Inflorescences are formed terminally on branches. The
plant is monoecious and flowers are unisexual.
Pollination is by insects.

After pollination, a trilocular ellipsoidal fruit is formed.
The exocarp remains fleshy until the seeds are mature.
The seeds are black and in the average 18 mm long (11 –
30) and 10 mm wide (7 – 11). The seed weight (per 1000)
is about 727 g, this are 1375 seeds per kg in the average.

The life-span of the Jatropha curcas plant is more than 50
years.

Varieties

The Jatropha variety in Nicaragua has fewer, but larger fruits. The yield per ha seems to be
the same.

A non-toxic variety exists in Mexico which is used for
human consumption after roasting. It does not contain
Phorbol esters. (“This non-toxic variety of Jatropha
could be a potential source of oil for human
consumption, and the seed cake can be a good protein
source for humans as well as for livestock.”, Becker et
al, 1999).

1.2 Distribution

Main distribution areas of Jatropha curcas (green)

Jatropha curcas originates from Cental America.

From the Caribbean, Jatropha curcas was probably distributed by Portuguese seafarers via the
Cape Verde Islands and former Portuguese Guinea (now Guinea Bissau) to other countries in
Africa and Asia. Today it is cultivated in almost all tropical and subtropical countries as
protection hedges around gardens and fields, since it it not browsed by cattle.

ripe Jatropha fruits

Jatropha seeds from Mali (left) and Nicaragua

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

1.3 Ecology

Jatropha curcas L. is not a weed. It is not self propagating. It has to be planted.

It grows well with more than 600 mm of rainfall per year, and it withstands long drought
periods. With less than 600 mm it cannot grow except in special conditions like on Cape
Verde Islands, where the rainfall is only 250 mm, but the humidity of the air is very high (rain
harvesting).

It cannot stand frost. It survives a very light frost, but it looses all leaves. The production of
seeds will probably go down sharply.

2. Description of the Jatropha System

2.1 The Jatropha System

The Jatropha System is an integrated rural development approach. By planting Jatropha
hedges to protect gardens and fields against roaming animals, the oil from the seeds can be
used for soap production, for lighting and cooking and as fuel in special diesel engines. In this
way the Jatropha System covers 4 main aspects of rural development:

promotion of women (local soap production);

poverty reduction (protecting crops and selling seeds, oil and soap).

erosion control (planting hedges);

energy supply for the household and stationary engines in the rural area;

The obvious advantage of this system is that all the processing procedure, and thus all added
value, can be kept within the rural area or even within one village. No centralised processing
(like in the cotton industry) is necessary.

2.2 Possible Uses of the Jatropha Plant

The Jatropha plant is used as a medicinal plant:

The seeds against constipation;

The sap for wound healing;

The leaves as tea against malaria; etc.

Jatropha is planted in the form of hedges around gardens or fields to protect the crops
against roaming animals like cattle or goats;

Jatropha hedges are planted to reduce erosion caused by water and/or wind;

Jatropha is planted to demarkate the boundaries of fields and homesteads;

Jatropha plants are used as a source of shade for coffee plants in Cuba;

In Comore islands, in Papua New Guinea and in Uganda Jatropha plants are used as a
support plant for vanilla plants;

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

3. Jatropha promotion in selected countries

3.0 Benin

There is no knowledge about actual activities. But Benin, in former times Dahomey, exported
in the years around 1940 lage quantities of Jatropha to France (Marseille), where the oil was
used for the fabrication of the famous “Savon de Marseille”.

In the years around 1990, the director of CADER Attakora in Natitingou, in the north of
Beninn, started a campaign of the dissemination of Jatropha hedges in the north of Benin.

3.1 Egypt

(see more photos:

http://www.jatropha.de/egypt/index.htm

)

In the desert near Luxor a 5.000 ha Jatropha plantation is
installed in 2003 by D1, an English biodiesel company in
collaboration with the Egyptian government. Irrigation with
waste water.

3.2 Ethiopia

In the south of Ethiopia Jatropha is used in the form of
hedges. In Addis Ababa a biodiesel company was founded
which wants to exploit Jatropha in a large scale for biodiesel production.

3.3 Ghana

(see Annex 2)

A private firm, Anuanom Industrial Project Ltd, is starting a large scale Jatropha project.

The planning is for 250.000 hectares of Jatropha plantation. Up to now there are no real
serious figures about the state of development available. A report mentions that 100 ha of
Jatropha are alrerady planted to deliver seeds for the extension of the industrial plantations.

The Jatropha oil will be used for the production of biodiesel.

UNDP extends it project MFP (multi functional platforms) to Ghana.

3.4 Guinea (Conakry)

Guinea has a high density of Jatropha plant (mostly hedges, in the Fouta Jallon area), but
there are no reports about activities/projects.

UNDP extends it project MFP (multi functional platforms) to Ghana.

3.5 Madagascar

In the years around 1940, Madagascar was exporting
Jatropha seeds to Marseille, France, as raw material for
soap production (“Savon de Marseille”). There are still
large quantities of Jatropha hedges, but their seeds are
more or less not used.

3.6 Mali

GTZ-Projects (1987 – 1997)

(see Jatropha website

www.jatropha.org

)

Jatropha hedge in Madagascar

5.000 ha Jatropha plantation

irrigated with waste water

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Within the “Special Energy Programme” of GTZ Jatropha activities commenced in 1987 and
continued in different organisational forms until 1997. The Malian partner of the GTZ project
was DMA and CNESOLER.

During the GTZ projects basic studies were carried out on the density of Jatropha hedges in
different regions of the country, on the yield of the hedges, on the oil yield of the expellers
and the ram presses, on the economy of soap
production and the use of Jatropha oil as diesel
substitute. Also studies were undertaken on the
value of the Jatropha presscake as an organic
fertiliser.

At the end of the GTZ projects, in 1997, the
population of Jatropha was estimated at around
10.000 km of Jatropha hedges, which represents a
potential of about 2.000 tons of Jatropha oil.

UNIDO / UNDP

UNDO/UND started a large scale project to disseminate “Multifunctional Energy Platforms
(MFP)” in the rural areas of Mali. 450 units are planned, and 15 %, i. e. almost 70 units,
should run with Jatropha oil as fuel.

This programme will be extended to Senegal, Guinea, Côte d’Ivoire and Ghana.

Description of the platform

(from website

www.ptfm.net

)

Essentially, it comprises a 10 H.P diesel engine, capable of driving up to a dozen different
ancillary modules. Among are a grain mill, a de-huller, a shea butter press and even an
electric alternator. This alternator can drive modules such as a water pump, provide power for
up to 250 light bulbs, charge batteries, drive a sawmill or weld metal. The platform employs
simple and appropriate technology and is an economic, practical and sustainable solution for
many of the problems faced by rural communities. Local artisans are trained to master all
aspects of this simple and appropriate technology.

Mali Folkecenter

Mali Folkecenter, a NGO in Bamako, took up the Jatropha activities in 2000, which were
carried out by GTZ between 1987 and 1997. In the meantime CNESOLER was in charge of
the Jatropha activities (CNESOLER was the national partner of the GTZ project). Mali
Folkecenter gets financial support from the Siemenpuu Foundation in Finland.

UNIFEM price 2003

(German UNIFEM Section)

In 2003 the Jatropha project in Mali, started by GTZ and continued by Mali Folkecenter,
received the 2

price of the German UNIFEM branch.

3.7 Mozambique

As a former Portuguise colony, in some areas there are large populations of Jatropha hedges.
From Mozambique the knowledge of the Jatropha hedges invaded Zimbabwe, Malawi and
Zambia.

The South African Oil & Gas Company “Sasol Technology (Pty) Ltd” built a gas pipeline
from South Mozambique to Johannesburg, South Africa. Along the pipeline they initiated
activities of rural development. The project manager in charge of these community
development activities explains the objective of these activities as follows: The objective is to
do rural development to let the population participate in the economic benefits of the pipeline.

old Jatropha hedge around a field

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

He intends to create small as well as large Jatropha plantations in the neighborhood of the
pipeline.

3.8 Namibia

There are some initiatives to plant Jatropha in Namibia, mostly from white farmers. But the
climate (rainfall is not sufficient) does not allow Jatropha plantation in a larger extent.

3.9 Senegal

A project carried out by ATI (now Enterprise Works), an
American NGO, in the region of Tiès, planted Jatropha
hedges and extracted Jatropha oil with ram presses. The oil
was used to run Diesel engines (for flower mills) and to
make soap.

3.10 South Africa

Emerald Oil Int. (Pty) Ltd

is initiating a 100.000 tons per year biodiesel plant in Durban.

It tries to organise the production of the feedstock for the plant (Jatropha curcas seeds) in
South Africa or to import it from the neighboring countries (Zimbabwe, Malawi, Zambia)
or from Madagascar.

supports the Agricultural Extension Service of KwaZulu-Natal to establish large scale

plantations of Jatropha hedges.

Owen Sithole College of Agriculture (OSCA)

The college has a very small Jatropha test plantation
(100 plants) in co-operation with the Agricultural
Extension Service, KwaZulu-Natal.

The

Agricultural Extension Service, KwaZulu-Natal

is very active in promoting the plantation of Jatropha in
the Makatini flats just south of Swaziland at the coast of
the Indian Ocean. For this it formed a Jatropha Task
Team, which also organises public field days (see
annex 14, page 48).

3.11 Sudan

(

http://www.jatropha.de/sudan/index.html

)

Jatropha is found in Sudan in many areas such as Khartoum State in Central Sudan,
Kassala State in the East and Kordofan State in the West. However, it is dominant in the
Southern States especially in Bahr El Jebel and Bahr El Gazal States. It is mentioned as an
indigenous plant in some books describing the plants of
Sudan. The farmers in the south plant them as hedges to
protect their gardens and fields.

Jatropha Research started in Sudan as early as 1972 with
studies concerning the molluscicidal effect of the plant.

A Jatropha Project exists in Kutum, North Darfur, with
participationof the German Development Service.

Soap from the ATI project

Jatropha plant in Kutum, North

Darfur, Sudan

Small Jatropha test plantation at

OSCA, KwaZulu-Natal

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

3.12 Tanzania

(

http://www.jatropha.de/tanzania/index.html

)

KAKUTE Ltd,

This firm disseminates the know how concerning “The
Jatropha System” and produces Jatropha soap in an
industrial scale. The dissemination is done within a project
called “ARI-Monduli” (Alternative Ressources of Income
for Monduli women). This project is financed by the
American McKnight Foundation and is executed in close
co-operation with Heifer International Foundation.

KAKUTE produces around
1.000 kg of soap a year and
sells it in form of pieces of 30 and 90 g each. Their revenues from
the sale of soap is about 6 million TZS (about 6.000 USD).

KAKUTE created a test plantation on private ground (2,5 ha) to
get experience with Jatropha
plantations.

KAKUTE tries to use Jatropha
against erosion: Between
Arusha and Lake Manyara is a
very big plain (Massai steppe).
A water line for cattle was
installed there and now Massai

cattle herds from far away come to get water. This led to an
overgrazing around the water basin and consequently to
deep erosion grooves. KAKUTE tries to plant Jatropha
against the erosion, but with little success, since the origin of
the overgrazing, the water source, still exists.

The project ARI-Monduli disseminates the Jatropha know how in different ways:

Nurseries

A women group of 12 members about 20 km from
Arusha started to integrate Jatropha in their tree
nurseries. They sell each seedling for about 50 TSh to
individuals and schools, which plant them around their
compounds.

Jatropha soap produced by

KAKUTE

Test plot of KAKUTE with

Jatropha cuttings

Erosion in the Massai plains

Members of Women group

producing Jatropha seedlings

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Plantation in Teachers Training School,

In a teachers training school a 2 ha area was planted
with Jatropha seedlings (more than 2.000) in the
beginning of 2002. In mid 2003 the first seeds could
be collected.

This plantation was also used as a site to inform the
population about the advantages of “the Jatropha
System” by organisinfg a public field day.

Soap making women group in Mto Wa Mbu

A women group in Mto Wa Mbu buys Jatropha oil from Engaruka and makes soap from
it. They sell this Jatropha soap for a very good price.

Seed collecting, oil extracting and soap making women groups in Engaruka

There are 2 women groups in Engaruka who collect Jatropha seeds and extract the oil.
Part of the oil is sold to the Jatropha soap women group in Mto Wa Mbu, the other part
they process themselfes to soap. KAKUTE started this activities about two years ago
within the ARI-Monduli project.

Mto Wa Mbu

A women group in Mto Wa Mbu, a town just besides the Manyara lake on the way to the
Ngorongoro Crater, buys every month 20 litres of Jatropha oil from the first women group of

Engaruka for 2.000 TZS per litre (2 USD).

From this oil they produce about 40 kg of soap and sell
this for about 126.000 TZS (120 USD), a piece of about
100 g for 500 TZS. Since soap making is an easy
process and does not
require much labour,

this is economically a very interesting business (details
see page 21).

The Jatropha soap has the immage of a medical soap. It is
produced by the women group within a dispensary and is
sold by women in other dispensaries. Many different
medicinal properties are attributed to the Jatropha soap (it
helps against different skin diseases). This is why the
soap can be sold for such a good price.

Simple method to produce soap bars

Sale of Jatropha soap in a dispensary

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Jatropha hedge besides the market place in

Engaruka

Engaruka

The village of Engaruka, just at the borderline of
Ngorongoro Conservation area, has a high density of
Jatropha hedges. Almost all gardens within the village
are surrounded/protected by Jatropha hedges. The origin
of the plants is not known, but they are there since
people remember. One saying goes that the Germans
introduced it during their colonial time before 1918. The
village is divided into two sections. Each has a women
group of about 30 women, all married and almost all
Massai. Since two years they collect Jatropha seeds.
First they only collected seeds and sold the seeds to
KAKUTE for about 150 TZS per kg. Now they extract
oil with a ram press and get 2.000 TZS per litre. This is
about 1.250 TZS more and needs about 1 hour of labour

(yield of the rampress is about 1 litre per hour).

The women told us, that befor they went to
collect wood to sell it to have some money.
Now they don’t have to collect firewood for
sale anymore. And soon they intent to stop
selling the oil and make soap and sell the soap,
what they are already doing to a certain extend.

KAKUTE is in charge of this project. To
assure that the Jatropha activities stay in the
hands of the women, Kakute refuses to buy
seeds from men. So if men want to get money
by collecting Jatroph seeds, they have to sell
them first to the women.

Vyahumu Trust

The VYAUMU TRUST is a project of ELCT (Evangelical Lutheren
Church of Tanzania) to improve the income of Tanzanian farmers by
enabling them to produce sunflower oil and to sell it directly. This
improves their income from sunflower farming by 100 to 200 %

The Vyahumu Trust produces the oil expeller, a key element for the
production of Jatropha oil, which was developed by order of GTZ to be
produced and used in Nepal with the name”Sundhara” expeller. In
Tanzania this expeller is named “Sayary”
expeller. The VYAHUMU TRUST assures also
the pre sale and after sale service.

3.13 Uganda

Jatropha hedge planted by the autochtone

population

Sayari-expeller for sunflower seed

oil extraction in Mlali, Tanzania

Sale of Jatropha soap in a shop in Engaruka

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Mr. Matthias Goergen, a consultant for GTZ, reported about Jatropha hedges planted by
the autochtone population in Uganda (West Nile Province). But they are planted as well
by the refugees in the camps, who do subsistence agriculture on small plots (0,3 to 0,5 ha
per person). It seems that the population does not use the Jatropha fruits. The hedges are
used only for fencing.

Mr. Alex Baudet founded a biodiesel company in Uganda (Uganda Biofuels Ltd. in

JONAM COUNTY in NEBBI district

In Uganda, Jatropha trees are used as a support for the vanilla.

3.14 Zambia

In Zambia, mainly in the areas near the border to Mozambique, large quantities of Jatrpha
hedges exist. But generally the population neglects the use of the seeds. The hedges serve as a
protection device against cattle.

In Lusaka a 2 ha test plantation exists, which was
planted by the NCSR (Nations Council of
Scientific Research), by contract with a soap
production firm. The intention was to replace
imported tallow by Jatropha oil. After the soap
firm was sold, the management lost interest in the
Jatropha approach.

In Southern Province, besides the Lake Kariba,
Jatropha plants are well known to the population,
because workers, who returned from Zimbabwe,
brought seeds back home and planted them.

In 1999 an excursion trip with about 20 farmers
from Southern Province to the BUN Jatropha
project in Zimbabwe initiated a lot of enthusiasme
within the group of farmers. Almost all of them
started small Jatropha plantations or hedges. A
study from Malawi two years later mentioned 100
farmers who started to plant Jatropha.

3.15 Zimbabwe

Bun Project

(

http://www.jatropha.de/zimbabwe/bun.htm

)

The Jatropha project of BUN started 1996. It is funded by the Rockefeller Foundation, the
Australien Agency for International Development (AusAid) and the Royal Netherlands
Embassy.

The project is located in Makosa, near the Mozambiquan border. Jatropha plants are in
abundance there. Traditionally they are used as a live fence around homesteads and gardens.

The objectives of the project are:

Use of the plant as a source of oil for use as fuel (domestic and industrial use) and
for soap making;

Use of the press cake as organic fertilizer;

Use of the oil for lighting purposes;

Jatropha hedge around a homestead near

Choma

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Binga Trees Project

(

http://www.jatropha.de/zimbabwe/binga.htm

)

The Binga Trees Programme started off August 1996 with the aim to develop local resources
that appeared to be untapped in spite of their capacity to improve the living conditions of
Binga District's rural population of 105.000.

Important among the perceived under-utilised resources are a number of food and/or oilseed
producing trees such as the Moringa oleifera, the Jatropha curcas, the Cashew nut, and the
Trichilia emetica, which all have an obvious potential to improve the household food security
in a variety of ways

Environment of Africa

(

http://www.jatropha.de/zimbabwe/ea/ea-jcl-activities.htm

)

One community group of five members representing
both men and women has started up planting Jatropha
curcas in the urban areas of Chinotimba, Victoria Falls.
The group use both seedlings and cuttings of Jatropha.
The seedling are raised in own nurseries and the
cuttings are collected from existing fencing material in
the neighbourhood. Jatropha is mainly planted on
marginalized soil i.e. unused public areas and school
areas for fencing. The group involves the children and
the teachers from local schools in the planting project
and use the project as a teaching lesson for the children
to raise awareness of the environment and to take ownership of the trees. The management
and care of the plants is organized between the user group and administration of the school.

Planting of hedges in urban areas

Distribution of seeds to rural areas

Planting Jatropha in plantation

POPA (Plant Oil Producers Association)

POPA was founded in 1992 by Zimbabwean commercial farmers who wanted to produce
Jatropha oil in a large scale. Soon they discovered that the profit margin concerning Jatropha
oil as fuel was not so big as they expected, especially because there was no possibility of
mechanical harvesting of the Jatropha seeds. The activities of POPA slowed down.

4. Impacts of the promotion of the use of Jatropha

4.1 Social impacts

Gender issues

(who does the work, who gets the money, changes of the distribution of the

workload, changes of the social status)

Mali

the Jatropha hedges belong to the men, who are the owner of the land. The

women can collect the seeds to make soap at a subsistence level. As soon as the

JCL-nursery near Victoria Falls

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

women want to make money by selling soap, the men open their hands and ask for
money, because they are the owners of the Jatropha hedges.

Because of this situation, the women didn’t want to give their earned money to the
men. They only produced the soap in small quantities for the own family, but they did
not use the potential of seeds on the hedges of the family.

It seems that since the years of 1997, the situation improved in favour of the women,
because the men (village chief) gave them plots to grow Jatropha.

Tanzania

, the situation is different. As in Mali, the land is owned by the men. But

the women have the right to collect the seeds from the family hedges, and to process
or sell them. The money is for them. Also the village gave them plots where they can
plant Jatropha for their own profit.

Zambia

the author was told, that the situation is like in Tanzania, described above.

About the situation in

Zimbabwe

, there are no information.

People without own farm land

(accessibility of seed, Jatropha in public forests for free

collection)

In the projects and regions visited, there were no “wild” Jatropha trees. All Jatropha
trees were planted as protection hedges, i. e. there was always an ownership of a
family. And only members of the family were allowed to collect seeds.

Other social issues, like cultural/religious traditions

(in some countries women are not

allowed to own trees or farm land), or indigenous knowledge

Mali

as well as in

Tanzania

, women are not allowed to own farm land and trees.

But in both cases the responsibles for the distribution of the land gave some plots to
women groupss to grow Jatropha there.

Mali

, in 1997, this donation of a plot to the women group was renounced twice

after the women planted more than 1.000 seedlings. The women lost interest to try it a
third time.

Mali Folkecenter reported, that recently the situation changed and land was given to
women groups to grow Jatropha. This information has to be varified.

Concerning indigenous knowledge the soap making with oil from different oil fruits is
well known in Mali and has an old tradition. They often used Shea butter and ground
nut oil for soap making. Coustic soda, the only product which has to come from
outside the village, is well available on all the rural markets, even far from the big
cities. In this way, soap production with Jatropha oil improves the the food situation,
since no edible oils have to be used for soap making.

Zambia

the soap making technology is not known in the rural areas.

The situation in

Zimbabwe

and

Tanzania

concerning traditinal rural soap making is

not known.

Working places:

The large scale Jatropha plantation in Egypt needs to employ a big number

of workers to maintain the irrigation system, to harvest the seeds and to maintain the
plantation itself. The 5.000 ha plantation will need about 3,3 million working hours to collect
the seeds, which are about 15.000 working months or about 1.500 full time workers, as long
as no mechanical device to collect the seeds is invented.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

4.2 Ecological impacts

Biodiversity

(is Jatropha competing with other crops?) and on the genetic diversity of

the Jatropha species

Jatropha is not a weed. It does not propagate by itself, it has to be planted. The
author did not see any self propagation of tees even after some 30 years.

When the hedges are not maintained, more and more plants die (due to termites ?),
and the old hedge can only be guessed.

There are only three varieties of Jatropha known so far. And no selection process
to get high yield varieties has been done so far. These 3 varieties are:

Cape Verde variety

. These are small seeds (weight of 1.000 grains

is about 682 g, length of seed is about 16,8 mm). This variety is
found almost in all countries onf the world, except Central America.

Nicaragua variety

. This variety is different from the Cape Verde

variety by larger leafes, which have a more rounded form, and by
larger seeds (weight of 1.000 grains is about 878 g, length of seed is
about 20,3 mm). The yield of the trees seems to be the same,
because there are less fruits on a tree than with the Cape Verde
variety.

Non toxic Mexican variety

. (weight of 1.000 grains is between 524

g and 901 g). Birgit Schmook reports, that the seeds in the zone
around Misantla, Veracruz, are very appreciated by the population
as food.

Erosion and the desertification process

The Massai plain near Arusha is very
much endangered by erosion due to
overgrazing (see picture at right, the
reason is the installation of a permanent
water basin, which attracts cattle from a
large area). Kakute plants Jatropha trees,
which are not browsed by the animals, to
protect the soil.

The Massai women in Engaruka,
Tanzania, report, that they were cutting
trees and selling wood along the road to
get some income. Due to the revenues gained by the use of the Jatropha plant, they
don’t do this anymore, which protects the still existing trees. Their income is
higher with Jatropha. They received two plots from the village to install Jatropha
plantations.

Rehabilitation of degraded land

Erosion in the Massai plain near Arusha,

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Since Jatropha has a deep reaching tap root, it is able to “pump” minerals from the
depth of the soil to the surface. This leads to a rehabilitation of degraded land (see
also decision of Tamil Nadu State on waste land rehabilitation in annex 9.

Other environmental aspects of Jatropha promotion

The NGO Environnement Africa uses the plantation of Jatropha to raise awareness with
school children and teachers for environmental aspects: “The group involves the children
and the teachers from local schools in the planting project and use the project as a
teaching lesson for the children to

raise awareness

of the environment and to take

ownership of the trees”.

Jatropha plantations can play an important role in

carbon sequestration

. The existing

large scale project in Egypt and the planned large scale Jatropha projects in South Africa
and Ghana are calculated with an initial financement by the Trade of Emission Certificates
(see annex 10).

4.3 Economic impacts

Egypt

The 5.000 ha Jatropha plantation near Luxor is initiated by a British biodiesel firm, D1. An
important financial aspect is the money, which the project will receive from the trade of
emission certificates of CO

sequestration. Since no data have been made available by the

project, here is an estimation of the money the project can apply for:

1 ha has about 1.600 plant, each has after 7 years about 200 kg of biomass, including roots.
Dry matter content about 25 %. This gives a biomass of 80 tons dry matter per ha.

About half that weight is carbondioxid, i.e. 40 tons. The trade of emission certificates pays
between 3 and 4 USD per ton of CO

sequestration, which is about 150 USD per ha.

The 5.000 ha plantation can consequently calculate with financial aid of 750.000 USD due to
carbon sequestration

Mali

External evaluation of the Jatropha project

In 1995 a GTZ-expert in economy analysed the economic feasibility of the Jatropha
approach. He studied 2 versions of oil expelling: a hand operated ram press and a motor
driven Sundhara expeller. For the last he calculated 2 different engines: a cheap Indian
motor (Lister) with regularly breakdowns and a more solid German Hatz motor. The
summary and conclusions are added in

annex 6

Ram-press:

Mr. Wiemer states: The calculations for the hand operated Bielenberg press

indicate that the extraction of Jatropha oil with this equipment is not financially feasible
under field conditions in rural Mali.

Motor driven expeller:

Mr. Wiemer states: The results of the financial analysis indicate

that for the Lister version an internal rate of return on investment (IRR) of 49 % can be
projected. For the Hatz version, the profitability of the oil mill is lower (26 % IRR) due to
the more expensive equipment, but also carries a much lower risk of mechanical
breakdowns.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Sudan

Economic evaluation of the utilization of Jatropha seeds for soap making
(from Henning, mission report, Sudan, 2001)

This economic evaluation adds the costs of material and labour input for a soap production of
3 litres of oil, which gives 5 kg of soap, reduced by the value of the sold press cake.

harvesting of 12 kg of seeds

4 h work

Caustic soda, 0,5 kg

1,0 US$

Oil extraction (12 kg seeds, 3 l oil)

4 hours work

Soap making (5 kg soap) 1 hour work

Depreciation of oil press 0,24 US$

Sale of press cake 0,27 US$

Result:

5 kg of soap = 50 pieces of 100 g, one piece is worth 0,43 US$ (100 Sudan Dirham SD)
50 x 0,43 = 21,5 US$
minus caustic soda and depreciation, plus sale of press cake = 0,97 US$

economic result: 20,53 US$ for 1 production.

The minimum to live in Khartoum is 170 US$ (Information by the German Embassy). To
earn this money, 8,3 production cycles have to be made, i. e. 8,3 x 3 = 24,9 l of oil have
to be processed, which will take 8,3 x 9 = 74,7 hours of work. This is a work load of less
than two weeks.

i.e. with harvest of Jatropha seeds, oil extraction, soap making and sale a worker can
earn a monthly salary with about 75 hours work!

Tanzania

The follwing economic evaluation of activities of the use of the Jatropha plant is based on
experience of KAKUTE in its Jatropha project ARI-Monduli (Alternative Resources of
Income for Monduli women). The figures are ascertained by Kakute.

The economic calculation is differentiated between seed collection, oil extraction and soap
making. It is obvious, that the collection of seeds and its sale gives the least added value. Oil
extraction is more profitable than seed collection, but not as good as soap making. This
explains very clearly that the Massai women of Engaruka are not very much interested to sell
seeds or oil, they want to gain the added value of the whole production chain and sell only
soap.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Collection and sale of seeds

Collection of seeds: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

Collection of seeds: 2 kg in 1 hour

Sale of seeds: 150 TZS per kg

Value added for 1 hour work

300 TZS

0,29 USD per hour

Extraction and sale of oil

Oil extraction: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

5 kg of seed for 1 litre of oil is 1,7 hours of work

1,0 hours of work to extract 1 litre of oil

Input:

5 kg of seed

750 TZS

0,71 USD per litre

1,5 hours of work to extract 1 litre of oil

depreciation of ram press 0,02 USD / kg

for 5 kg:

105 TZS

0,10 USD per litre

Output:

Sale of 1 litre of oil

2.000 TZS

1,90 USD

Value added for 1 hour of work

1.145 TZS

1,09 USD per hour

Production and sale of soap

Soap making: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

16 hours work for 252 bars of soap

1 bar sold for 500 TZS

Purchase of 20 litres of oil à 2.000 TZS = 40.000

Purchase of 3 kg of Caustic Soda à 2.000 TZS = 6.000 TZS

Plasic for wrapping soap = 3.000 TZS

10 hours for miscelenous work (organising purchase of oil, wrapping the soap, etc)

Input:

20 l oil

40.000 TZS

38,10 USD

Plastic

3.000 TZS

2,86 USD

Caustic Soda

6.000 TZS

5,71 USD

Total input for 26 hours work

49.000 TZS

46,67 USD

Output:

252 bars à 500 TZS

126.000 TZS 120,00 USD

Total of revenues

77.000 TZS

73,33 USD

Value added for 1 hour of work

2.962 TZS

2,82 USD per hour

Zambia

Jatropha oil as diesel substitute

(for details see annex 7)

In a feasibility study in 1998, the author stated, that Jatropha oil can be produced for less
than 3.000 ZMK (1000 ZMK = 0,41 USD). But this is a prohibitive price for the use of
the oil as diesel substitute.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Jatropha oil for soap making

(for details see annex 7)

The economy of soap making depends very much on the price for Jatropha seeds. If the
price is fixed to 500 ZMK (which is 0,21 USD or duble the price of seeds in Mali), a piece
of soap is calculated to 248 ZMK, about half the price of cheap industrial soap. Women of
a women group in Mazabuka confirmed, that the Jatropha soap can be sold for about
1.000 ZMK a piece, i. e. 4 times the production price).

If the price for seeds is raised to 1.000 ZMK (4 times the price for seeds in Mali), the price
for soap raises only to about 373 ZMK, which is still less than the cheapest industrial soap
and about a third of the price, the women group of Mazabuka suggests.

If the calculation is done only by using the working hours for seed collection and oil
extraction, plus material, the profit for 1 hour of work is calculated to be more than 1.000
ZMK (1.007 ZMK), that is more than duble the wage as payed for rural labour (400
ZMK).

Answers to distinct questions of the Terms of Reference:

The best documentated data concerning the economy of the use of the Jatropha tree were
found in Tanzania, in the ARI-Monduli project of KAKUTE. The further down given answers
refer to KAKUTE, if not otherwise indicated.

Household income

(sale of seeds, production and sale of oil, production and sale of soap)

There are no data available concerning the financial effect of the profit of Jatropha
processing to the single households of the members of the women groups.

Household food security

(Jatropha is grown in form of hedges to protect food crops)

There are no data available concerning the amount of food saved by Jatropha hrges. In
Mali it was told by the CMDT (Malian Cotton Producing Society), that about 10 % of the
crops are eaten by roaming cattle. This might be an approximative value concerning the
protection of food crops by Jatropha hedges. Probably the real value is higher, because
food crops are grown in gardens within or near the village, where the density of roaming
animals is higher.

Farming systems

(integration of Jatropha into the farming calender, Jatropha as

integrated part of the farm design)

Before the beginning of the Jatropha project of GTZ in Mali a socio-economic study on
the feasibilty of the Jatropha approach was done (Keita). This study stated, that no major
conflict concerning the collection of Jatropha seeds and the agricultural works is visible
(see annex 12).

No documentation concerning farm design has been found in the countries the author has
visited. There is a document in Portuguese language from Quental Mendes, 1992, where
small farming units are proposed with Jatropha hedges as an integral part of them, mainly
for the boundaries between the fields and the farms (see annex 11).

The income situation in rural areas

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

No general remarks about the income situation in rural areas can be made. But a
description of the economy of soap production in different countries (see above) shows,
that this production as part of an integrated approach is economically very interesting.

In Tanzania, the profit of 1 hour’s work of soap making is more than 2 USD, which is a
phantatic profit marge, if the income of a technical person of a flower mill in the rural area
is only 10 USD a month.

Availability of renewable energy in the rural areas

(household energy, fuel)

No general statement about the availability of renewable energy in rural areas can be
made.

Wood as a renewable household energy for cooking is very scarce in the Massai region of
Tanzania. The interest to use Jatropha oil instead is very high. KAKUTE developed a
cooker for Jatropha oil, but the development is not yet completed.

In the Massai area between Lake Victoria and Iringa, a high density of Jatropha hedges
are reported. In this region the potential of plant oil as a renewable energy source for
cooking and lighting might be suffient to supply the household needs. A detailed study
has to varify this statement.

In Mali, in the regions of Jatropha use, the average village has a potential of 12 tons of
seed, which is 2.400 litres of oil. This quantity of a renewable fuel is at least far enough to
supply the village need for lighting and for flower milling, as well as for the electricity
production for lighting of the dispensary and the scool. It will be probably not enough for
the energetic needs for cooking for the whole village.

But some of the villages have up to 40 km of Jatropha hedges, which represents a quantity
of 6.400 litres of oil. This will probably cover all actual energy needs of the village.

Bosch-Siemens, a big German firm for household machines (washing machines,
refrigerators, stiirers etc) is developing a plant oil cooker, which will be tested in the
second half of 2004 in the Phillipines. This cooker works perfectly with plant oil and
should be sold for less than 30 USD, the head of the project stated.

Creation of small business units

(milling services, oil extraction services, entrepreneurs

who buy seed and sell oil or products, soap making, etc.)

In Tanzania the ELCT is running a project, VYAHUMU TRUST, to produce edible oil
from sunflower seeds to increase the income of the sunflower farmers (the oil is sold three
times the price of the sunflower seeds). The extraction of the oil is organised as a service
provided by small entrepreneuers who own a Sayari oil expeller (see photo page 14,
Vyahumu Trust).

SUDERETA, a NGO of ELCT, supported by BftW, is going to run a project on solar
lamps with a pure commercial approach. A book, Enterprise od Trust, describes this
approach (see attachment 13).

The women group of Engaruka can be regarded as a firm (30 members), which collects
seed for sale, but started to process also the other steps of the production chain, oil
extraction and soap making. In this way the whole added value stays within the village
(see page 12).

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

The women group of Mto Wa Mbu, described on page 11, forms such an economic unity,
which buys oil and the other inputs, produces soap and sells it. Their organisational form
is that of a women group, not a firm. But it could be regarded easily as a “Enterprise of
Trust”.

SUDERETA is very much interested to start a pilot project for the the utilisation of the
Jatropha plant .

Local, regional, international markets

(availability of energy in the rural area changes

the pattern of production, i. e. more edible oils may be produced, which improve the local
diet and replace imported edible oils)

Up to now the Jatropha activies are locally based and have no effect to other regions. With
the large plantation in Egypt (which will go into full production in 2007) this will change.
Then oil may be traded as it is done now with edible oils.

South Africa tries to import seeds or oil in large quantities as raw material for the start of a
biodiesel production, until the own plantations will be able to produce.

Until now South Africa imported 5 tons of seed from Zimbabwe, and has a contract of 60
tons from Zambia.

To start the Jatropha plantation in Egypt, the project had to import about 15 tons of seed.
The seeds came from India.

A German firm imported 500 l of Jatropha oil from Tanzania for engine tests.

Besides of the above mentioned activities the author doesn’t have any information about
substantial trade of Jatropha seeds, oil or soap outside local markets.

5. Critical assessment of the Jatropha System, based on findings

In the various African countries the utilization of this plant is spreading. In all the countries
mentioned in this report, the plant is already there and the farmers use it mainly as live fences
around homesteads, gardens and fields. Also the seeds are used in some countries in West
Africa by women to produce soap in a traditional way.

Only since a few years many GOs and NGOs and private companies show interest in the
possibilities which the use of this plant can offer. 2 main aspects are predominant in the use of
the plant:

NGOs working in rural areas are interested in the income generating possibilities by
the utilization of the Jatropha plant, maily for oil for soap making.

Some government organisations and private companies are interested in the energetic
aspect by using Jatropha oil for the large scale production of biodiesel. The carbon
sequestration effect of Jatropha plantations seems to play an important role in the
financement of these large projects.

Economic evaluation of these 2 ways of using Jatropha oil:

Soap production:

The economy of soap production is positiv in all the cases were data were available.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

In the case of Tanzania, were the most and the most recently collected data were available, the
economy of soap production shows impressing profit. The profit changes within the different
steps of the processing chain.

The first step, the collection of seeds, shows the lowest income for 1 hour of work,
only 0,29 USD per hour.

The second step, oil extraction by the hand operated ram press, shows an income
of 0,73 USD per hour, i. e. almost 3-fold the income of seed collection.

The third step, the production of soap from the Jatropha oil, shows the highest
profit, 2,82 USD per hour.

This third point explains, why the firm KAKUTE in Arusha, Tanzania, can exist by producing
and selling Jatropha soap. Due to its Jatropha promotion activities they are able to buy cheap
seeds in areas with high Jatropha potential. The women, who sold the seeds, are aware of the
situation and decided, not to sell seeds anymore, but to process them, to oil and soap and sell
that.

Jatropha oil as fuel:

Jatropha oil in Tanzania (Arusha, Engaruka, Mto Wa Mbu) is traded in small quantities for 2
USD per litre. This is 3-times the price of Diesel fuel at the filling station.

This means, it is economically not interesting to use Jatropha oil as diesel substitute. If
somebody has Jatropha oil, he sells it to soap makers or produces soap himself, and buys
diesel with the profit.

This is the reason, why KAKUTE offers lamps and cookers for the use of Jatropha oil, but
this seems to be an alibi, and there is not much interest by the population. Petrol for lighting
and cooking is cheaper, if it is available.

Jatropha plantations:

It is not clear, why goverments (Egypt) and private firms (D1) are so much interested in
producing biodiesel with Jatropha oil. The autor has not yet seen any economic calculation,
which shows, that the biodiesel from Jatropha oil might be cheaper than the diesel fuel.

It seems, that these organisations prepare for a sharp increase of fossil fuel prices, and want to
get the technology ready to produce renewable fuel. With higher fuel pricec, this seems
economically viable.

The money received by selling Certified Emission Reductions is just a financial help to start
such large. Jatropha plantations.

Gender Aspects:

Mali:

Soap production with Jatropha oil, in Mali as well as in Tanzania, seems to be a very
priftzable activity. But in Mali there has not been a growth of this activity as expected.
The seeds on the trees were not collected. The women used the technology (oil extraction
and soap making), but only to a very limited extend. The reason seems to be the
following:

The men own the land and therefor also the Jastropha hedges. The women collect the
seeds and make soap. Traditionally this soap was just for the use in the family.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

With the new technology (oil extraction), the women can produce a really good soap and
sell it for a high price. They can “really” earn money. The men asked for part of the
money, because the hedges are theirs. The women refused, so the men refused to give the
women the right to collect the seeds from the hedges.

Now the women use the new technology only in a very small extend, just to produce the
soap for the family. The possible economic impact has to wait until the socio-economic
conditions allow the women to use the Jatropha seeds to full extend and keep the money
for themselves.

Tanzania:

In Tanzania, the men are as in Mali the owners of the land and of the Jatropha hedges.
And the women collect the seeds, extract the oil and make soap. But in Tanzania the
women can keep the money for them. The men don’t interfere. This is the reason why in
Tanzania the utilization of Jatropha had much more impact in a short time (2 years) than
in Mali (10 years).

As a conclusion, one can say, that there are no hints, that the following central hypothesis is
wrong:

The Jatropha System creates a positive reciprocity between raw material/energy

production and environment/food production.

i. e. the more seeds/oil Jatropha hedges produce, the more food crops are protected from animals and erosion.

Also additional income is created, mainly for women.

It may still take some time, until the Jatropha System will contribut economically to the rural
development in a large scale. But it seems, that the activities of many different organisations
more and more suppport the Jatropha approach.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

6. Bibliography

Becker et al, Studies on Propagation of non-toxic variety of Jatropha curcas, Stuttgart,
Germany, 1999;

Breitenstein/Shila, Enterprise of Trust – economic welfare in rural areas through the use
of renewable energies, 2002

Gübitz et al, Biofuels and Industrial Products from

Jatropha curcas

, developed from the

Symposium “Jatropha 97”, Managua, Nicaragua, Febr. 1997

Heller, Joachim, Physic Nut – Jatropha curcas L.; IPGRI - International Plant Genetic
Resources Institute,1996;

Henning, Reinhard K., The Jatropha System in Zambia – Evaluation of the existing
Jatropha activities and proposals for an implementation strategy in Southern Province of
Zambia, 1999 (non published feasibility study);

Henning, Reinhard K., The Jatropha website

http://www.jatropha.org

, 1997 – 2004;

Henning, Reinhard K., Combating Desertification by integrated Utilization of the Jatropha
plant – Experiences of the Jatropha Project in Mali, West Africa, 1997;

Henning, Reinhard K., Jatropha Development Project to the Sudan – Report of a Mission
to UNIDO, Khartoum, 2001, unpublished;

Keita, Anne, Production et Utilisation de l’Huile de Pourghère comme Carburant au Mali
– Aspects Socio-Economiques, Bamako, 1992

Quental Mendes, Ministerio da Agricultura, Direc

o de Economia Agr

ria, Para uma

Agricoltura Camponesa de Aldeia, Maputo 1992

Schmook, Birgit, Jatropha curcas L. Gensammlung Halbinsel Yucatan und
Veracruz/Mexico, 1996

Wegmershaus, R. Oliver, G.; Jatropha curcas in Zimbabwe, Growers Handbook; Plant Oil
& Engine Development Group Ptv. Ltd., Harare, 1993 (non published copy);

Wiemer, Hans-Jürgen, Financial and Economic Analysis of the Jatropha System, Report
for GTZ, 1996;

7. Attachments:

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 1 - ToR of Jatropha Case Study

Case Study „Jatropha curcas L.”

Assessment of the impact of the dissemination of “the Jatropha System” on the ecology of the
rural area and the social and economic situation of the rural population (target group) in
selected countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America.

Objectives of the case study:

As indicated in the study of Dr. Heller in the IPGRI-publication “Physic nut – Jatropha curcas
L. Promoting the conservation and use of underutilized and neglected crops”, Jatropha curcas
has the potential of an important role in integrated rural development.

7 years after the publication of that study it would be important to see in practice, if the
development potential of that crop can be directed into rural development, or if there are
serious unforeseen difficulties (side effects), which oppose to the dissemination of this
approach for sustainable rural development.

Worldwide there are many NGOs and national and international organizations, which adopted
the Jatropha System to integrate it into their activities. The experiences of these organisations
should be evaluated to compare the real development impacts with the predicted ones.

This case study should evaluate the impact of the production and use of Jatropha oil on the
ecological situation of the rural area and the social and economic situation of the rural
population.

Study outline:

1. Description of the plant, distribution, ecology, uses

2. Description of the Jatropha-System

3. Jatropha promotion in selected countries

Africa: Mali, Sudan, Cape Verde, Southafrica, Zambia, Zimbabwe, Tanzania
Asia: India
Latinamerica: Nicaragua,

4. Impacts of the promotion of the use of Jatropha

4.1 Social impacts e.g. on:

gender issues (who does the work, who gets the money, changes of the distribution of
the workload, changes of the social status)

people without own farm land (accessibility of seed, Jatropha in public forests for free
collection);

other social issues, like cultural/religious traditions (in some countries women are not
allowed to own trees or farm land), or indigenous knowledge

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

4.2 Ecological impacts e.g. on:

biodiversity and on the genetic diversity of the Jatropha species

erosion and the desertification process

rehabilitation of degraded land

4.3 Economic impacts e.g. on:

household income (sale of seeds, production and sale of oil, production and sale of soap);

household food security (Jatropha is grown in form of hedges to protect food crops)

farming systems (integration of Jatropha into the farming calender, Jatropha as integrated
part of the farm design)

the income situation in rural areas

availability of renewal energy in the rural areas (household energy, fuel)

creation of small business units (milling services, oil extraction services, entrepreneurs
who buy seed and sell oil or products, soap making, etc)

local, regional, international markets (availability of energy in the rural area changes the
pattern of production, i. e. more edible oils may be produced, which improve the local diet
and replace imported edible oils)

5. Critical assessment of the Jatropha-System based on the findings

6. Bibliography

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 2 - Jatropha in Ghana

Jatropha activities in Ghana

Since 2002, Jatropha Hamburg is the German cooperation partner of the Anuanom
Biodiesel Project in Ghana. Though being a private enterprise initiative, the long-term
socio-economic benefits of the Anuanom project have been recognised by the Ghanaean
government. The production of bio-energy will have various positive effects for Ghana: the
country has no own petroleum resources. The necessary importation of fossil fuels is a
constant socio-economic effort, which has the same well-known effects as in other
developing countries without petroleum: fuel shortage, high trade deficit, foreign
indeptedness, lack of foreign exchange. At the same time, the lack of income perspectives in
rural regions tends to increase the migration from the land to the cities, creating idle
farmland on the one hand, growing poverty populations in cities on the other hand. The
familiar picture.
The Ghanaean government supports this project, because it will generate income for rural
regions and, in the long run, will reduce the dependency on petroleum imports at the same
time. The ministries of agriculture and energy, as well as the Presidential Office have
documented their interest in the development of the project in written statements. In
practice this means that authorization procedures are accelerated, and a purchase
commitment is granted to the producers of biodiesel, which means the nation-wide
marketing will be handled by the state.

Current State of Development and Planning

Cultivation of Jatropha curcas L.

Anuanom operates a pilot plantation of ca. 100 ha which currently serves the production of
Jatropha seeds. A highly productive variety bearing nuts with an oil content of 60-67% is
raised here.
The seeds are delivered to farmers in the country, who want to participate in the production
of Jatropha curcas L.. Since 2000, an incentive program promotes the cultivation of Jatropha
curcas. This agricultural program is granted international support by ADRA, an American
NGO, as the organization in charge, and by the UNDP co-financing it with 50.000 USD. The
Ghanaean Ministry of Agriculture backs up with personnel who promote Jatropha curcas L. in
meetings with rural Local Assemblies giving information and training around the cultivation
of the plant.
Up to the present (May 2002) a total of ca. 2000 ha has been planted in Greater-Accra-
Region, Eastern Region and Western Region. The planted area is increasing by the week.
The growth rate of plantations is expected to be boosted during 2003, when the processing
production starts as planned, and the first harvest deliveries prove to yield cash income for
growers. Up to 2004/2005, an increase of the total cultivating area to 250.000 ha is planned.
This would be around a quarter of the total idle farmland in Ghana.

Products and Markets

Oil is won from the Jatropha nuts by cold-pressing. A part of it can flow back into the
production process as generator fuel, or can be marketed as fuel. It is planned for the future

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

to generate electricity for the local energy market.
Biodiesel is won by esterification of the oil with ethanol. Ethanol – unlike methanol which
is a petroleum product and would have to be imported – can be won from local agricultural
products as sugar cane. The centralized nation-wide marketing of the biodiesel is done by
the Ministry of Energy. This appears to make sense for Ghana, because the petroleum
importation is governmental , too. However, the project operators maintain the right to
market an unlimited quantity of biodiesel on their own.
Glycerin, the by-product of the esterification process, is to be purified and can then be sold
on an extensive market. During the first stage, the demand in Ghana will be sufficient to buy
the entire production. The market price is 500-600 USD/ton.
The presscake is modified and sold as biological fertilizer, also primarily on the local
market; but import agents from neighbouring countries in West Africa, such as Nigeria, have
already confirmed their interest to be supplied.

Production and Plants

In 2003, the Anuanom project will enter a critical stage. The agricultural program will then
deliver its first harvested production. The first production unit must be built up by then, and
the money must be ready to be paid to the growers.
As far as possible, manufacturers in Ghana will be taken as contractors to build the plant. For
technical reasons, some of the components are to be manufactured in or bought from
Europe:

Oil-presses: stamping presses operating with 70-100 tons of pressure are needed for the

cold-pressing of the Jatropha nuts. Minimum capacity: 50 tons of nuts/day, equivalent of the
expected harvested quantity of ca. 1000 tons/month during 2003/2004.

Stainless steel tank with mixer for the production of biodiesel; capacity: 10.000 l. Currently

we are checking the market for used equipment fit for the purpose, e.g. from the dairy
industry.

Distilling plant for ethanol; capacity: 200 tons of distillate/month = ca. 6-8 tons/day.

Purifying plant for glycerin.

Financing

Apart from the UN grant for the agricultural incentive program, the pre-production
development of the project has been entirely financed with private resources by the project
operators. A World Bank loan of 2 million USD has been signed and confirmed, the payment
of which will be released by 2005. 2 million USD is the estimated investment needed to put
up the first production unit and start operations in 2003. Our initiative group in Hamburg
cooperates closely with an Austrian consulting team in order to secure the knock-on
financing of the Anuanom project. This involves the application for governmental grants from
EU development funds as well as contacting prospective private investors here. For a private
engagement, an interest in a long-term investment would be essential.
Provided agricultural production goes on spreading as planned, the project will reach its
second stage in 2004/2005. This will make investments of ca. 10 million USD for further
production units necessary.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 3 - BUN Zimbabwe

PLANT OIL PRODUCTION AND UTILISATION (extract fron BUN
Zimbabwe newsletter)

The Plant Oil Project was successfully initiated at Makosa Mutoko, Zimbabwe in 1996 by
BUN-Zimbabwe. Funded by the Rockefeller Foundation, Australian Agency for International
Development (AusAid) and the Royal Netherlands Embassy, the plant oil project is expected
to provide income, provide alternative manure and be an ecologically friendly source of
alternative energy to rural farmers. Makosa is fortunate to have the oil plants in abundance.
The plants have traditionally been used as a live fence or hedge around homesteads and
gardens and are called “

jirimono

” in several parts of Zimbabwe.

The objectives of the project are the utilisation of the

Jatropha Curcas Linn

(JCL) plant

(

physic nut in English

) as a source of oil for use as fuel for domestic and industrial purposes,

and finding other uses of JCL. BUN originally facilitated the acquisition of three oil expellers
(two manual, one motorized) from local manufacturers for processing the seed into oil. The
oil is intended to be used in soap making and to a lesser extent in lamps for lighting purposes,
substituting paraffin which is the usual lighting fuel in rural homes.

The residue from the seed cake which is a good organic fertilizer is under investigation, with
promising initial results.

The community has received training in the use of the oil expeller and oil extraction is in
progress at Makosa. In addition six women from the community underwent training in soap
making. After training they formed a soap making group and it has shown early signs of
viability. The soap which lathers well, is of good quality and cheaper than most soaps.

Since the establishment of the venture, it has provided the community and other surrounding
areas with laundry soap. The women’s group has opened a savings account with a
commercial bank in Mutoko. Improvements in soap quality are still underway, backed up by
tests on samples sent to the Standards Association of Zimbabwe.

Lamps to utilize JCL oil as a fuel have been designed which have a lower fuel burning rate
than paraffin lamps. The lamps operating on different wick mechanisms are easy to make.

The trial use of JCL cake as an organic fertilizer was successful in 1998, showing the value of
the cake as manure. Trials will be conducted to determine the optimum application rate.

It is hoped that as the demand for JCL oil grows, more people will grow the hedges,
contributing to income generation through sale of seeds, and improvement of the
environment. The project is expected to grow and become a more commercially oriented
venture owned by the community. The Project hosted 19 Zambian trainees (farmers, NGOs
and civil servants) sponsored by GTZ Zambia, and numerous Zimbabwean and international
visitors and trainees.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 4 - Environment Africa

Environment

Africa

Victoria Falls

Branch

Who are

we?

Planting of hedges in urban areas

One community group of five members representing both men and women has started up
planting Jatropha curcas in the urban areas of Chinotimba, Victoria Falls. The group use both
seedlings and cuttings of Jatropha. The seedling are raised in own nurseries and the cuttings
are collected from existing fencing material in the neighbourhood. Jatropha is mainly planted
on marginalized soil i.e. unused public areas and schools areas for fencing. The group
involves the children and the teachers from local schools in the planting project and use the
project as a teaching lesson for the children to raise awareness of the environment and to take
ownership of the trees. The management and care of the plants is organized between the user
group and administration of the School.

Distribution of seeds to rural areas

Another Jatropha project involves the distribution of Jatropha seed to ten primary schools in
rural areas in Hwange North. Every School is giving 2000 seeds of Jatropha and also some
containers for planting the seeds. The intension is to commit the children and the schools to
start making nurseries and afterwards either sell or plant the seedlings in the areas close to the
school.

The idea is that Environment Africa in future will buy the seedling from the schools for about
200 z$ each and sell them as Tree Tickets. Tree Tickets is a concept where foundations or
individuals can donate trees to a local rural area selected by the donor. Environment Africa
will facilitate the planting and management of the trees.

The school can also chose to plant the seedlings later harvest the seed and then sell them to
Environment Africa for oil extraction. It’s the plan to start oil extraction at Chidobe
Information and Research centre for demonstration and commercial production. At the
moment Hlanganani Oil Pressing and Peanut Butter Making group has been donated a
Bielenberg ram presser by DED.

At the moment 12000 Jatropha seeds have been distributed in Hwange North.

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

An agreement with hotels etc regards collection of used water bottles. The bottles are used for
water dripping system in the nurseries and as planting containers.

Planting Jatropha in plantation

In the rural area 1 hectare planted with Jatropha (

Jatropha curcas

) mixed with other oil

species as Moringa (

Moringa oleifera

) and Neem (

Azadirachta indica

) are going to be

initiated as research plot for further investigation. The plantation is going to be based on
seedlings only.

Environment Africa
Box CT502
Chinotimba
Victoria Falls
Zimbabwe

Jatropha nursery

Jatropha cuttings

Planting of Jatropha seeds

Planting of Jatropha cuttings

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 5 - Jatropha KwaZulu-Natal

Emerald Oil International (Pty) Ltd. t/a Biodieselafrica

From the desk of Bernd Schmidt

Exploratory Mission

The purpose of the mission to explore the level of Jatropha Curcas cultivation and the
assessment of the capacities for and on behalf of the Department of Trade and Industry (dti) in
Kwa Zulu Natal.

On Wednesday 17

. And Thursday 18

.of December, Mr. Andre Kudlinski from dti and

Mr. Bernd Schmidt from Biodieselafrica, visited amongst others Jatropha farms and
institutions in KZN. We travelled about 800 Km. by Automobile.

At the first meeting on Wednesday morning in Durban with Dr. Sid Kelly, Chief Executive Officer of the
Richards Bay Industrial Development Zone (IDZ) Mr. Kelly has informed us, that the City of Richardsbay is
promoting the growing of Jatropha Curcas on farmland of 4000 ha. in size, to demonstrate, that the City is
standing behind the Bio Diesel project in Richards Bay. Funding made available by IDC.

Our Journey is heading north 200 Km. to Empangeni to visit the Owen Sithole
Agricultural College a Institution of the Department of Agriculture and Environmental
Affairs (DAEA) under the management of Mr. Joseph Foli. This institute is involved in
the growing of Jatropha and has been designated as the training facility for the
farmers of the vicinity.

Further North (180Km.) We visited the Agricultural research Centre of the DAEA near
Jozini at the Makatini Flats. This visit was quite impressing, the research centre has
produced a few thousand of Jatropha seedlings that are ready for distribution to the
farmers in this area. Their experimental plantation of Jatropha with some trees 18
month old, already producing large amount of seeds. Tree size about 1.50 meter
height. The amount of seed approximately 2.5 Kg. per tree. Photo material on hand.

We also met with local (Mtubatuba and Makatini Flats) farmers representatives
involved in the Jatropha project. We where informed, that a large amount of small-
scale farmers are already producing Jatropha.

Unfortunately, we run short of time so we couldn’t visit the largest ( 5 hectare) private
plantation of Jatropha in the Mtubatuba area. Nor could we visit the plantation of the
DAEA at Eshowe.

Mr. Kudlinski has recognised the urgent need for funds to start coordinated training of
Jatropha farmers and to finance the production and distribution of seedlings as well
as the purchase of additional seed. The many tons of Jatropha seed, available until
now in South Africa has been made available to the farming community exclusive by
Mr. Bernd Schmidt.
Mr. Kudlinski will incorporate his comments and findings from our visit into the
biodiesel project status report that should be ready by mid- January 2004.

Report by: Bernd Schmidt 19 December 2003

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 7 - Economic analysis of JCL utilization in Tanzania

Economy of Jatropha Utilization in Tanzania

data from KAKUTE, 2003

Collection of seeds: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

Collection of seeds: 2 kg in 1 hour

Sale of seeds: 150 TZS per kg

Value added for 1 hour work

300 TZS

0,29 USD per hour

Oil extraction: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

5 kg of seed for 1 litre of oil is 1,7 hours of work

1,0 hours of work to extract 1 litre of oil

Input:

5 kg of seed

750 TZS

0,71 USD per litre

1,5 hours of work to extract 1 litre of oil

depreciation of ram press 0,02 USD / kg

for 5 kg:

105 TZS

0,10 USD per litre

Output:

Sale of 1 litre of oil

2.000 TZS

1,90 USD

Value added for 1 hour work

1.145 TZS

1,09 USD per hour

Soap making: (figures from KAKUTE, 2003)

16 hours work for 252 bars of soap

1 bar sold for 500 TZS

Purchase of 20 litres of oil à 2.000 TZS = 40.000

Purchase of 3 kg of Caustic Soda à 2.000 TZS = 6.000 TZS

Plasic for wrapping soap = 3.000 TZS

10 hours for miscelenous work (organising purchase of oil, wrapping the soap, etc)

Input:

20 l oil

40.000 TZS

38,10 USD

Plastic

3.000

TZS

2,86

USD

Caustic

Soda

6.000

TZS

5,71

USD

Total input for 26 hours work

49.000 TZS

46,67 USD

Output:

252 bars à 500 TZS

126.000 TZS 120,00 USD

Total of revenues

77.000 TZS

73,33 USD

Value added for 1 hour of work

2.962 TZS

2,82 USD per hour

Jatropha curcas in Africa – an Evaluation

Reinhard K. Henning, bagani, Rothkreuz 11, D-88138 Weissensberg, Germany

e-mail:

henning@bagani.de

, Jatropha website:

www.Jatropha.org

Annex 10 - The role of Jatropha in of Carbon sequestration

ROJAC CONSULTANTS

Green Energy Technologies

INDIA

June '02

Dear. Mr.Reinhard K. Henning
Please accept our congratulations, some of our inspirations have been from your informative
web site.
We have carried out research on the use the jatropha curcas oil seed and all its parts for
energy purpose to make it an economically viable project. We can offer the know-how for
production of biodiesel, bio-gas and biomass as energy products and the oilseed cake is a
very good bio-fertiliser.
Based on our research our project was selected for presentation at the 3

International

Investment Forum for Sustainable Energy. The presentation was on the 17

of April '02 at

Hanover in Germany.
Funds can be arranged for large size project of 50,000 to 200,000hectares, after the initial
investment the project can expand from the sale of carbon saved, as these are all green energy
technologies. The involvement of the local Government is a must for this project.
Best regards
LUCAS ROSARIO
Chief Executive