Drowned in Sound

Search


Drowned in Sound Event sponsored tours and events.

Bambi's Dilemma

Melt Banana: Bambi's Dilemma

no votes
?
by Ben Yates
  • Type: Album
  • Release date: 30/04/2007
  • Label: A-Zap

Bambi’s Dilemma – the follow up to Melt Banana's pretty-damn-fine career highlight Cell Scape – has been three years in the waiting. The band's traditional fan contingent – disconcerted with the poppier direction that the last few records have taken – will be pleased with this album. The first half sees them veer even further into pop territory, while the second is something of a homecoming with a revisiting of the half-a-minute noise explosions that defined their early releases. Whether they’re toying with 'Hey Mickey'-style vocal parts or retesting the trademark double-speed aural fuckery, Bambi’s Dilemma sends out a clear message that the Japanese trio are worth the three-year wait.

So what of these aforementioned pop parts? Those worrying that Melt Banana have gone soft should relax their apprehension – they’ve kept the ear-splitting noisier-than-thou guitar interruptions, the strange electronic interludes and the breakneck-speed rhythmic irruptions. But they’ve made more use of melody, and Yasuko Onuki’s vocals – although still indecipherable – sound even more like those of a high-school cheerleader. 'Blank Page Of The Blind' is the album’s highlight, in part due to Ichirou Agata’s ear-piercing guitar solo that carries the power of 1,000 exploding stars. It’s a potent reminder of why he’s been described as one of the best guitarists in the world, i.e. because he is.

As Melt Banana enter their fifteenth year in operation, there have been calls from the fans of the early albums to return to the outbursts of noise that gained them a reputation in the beginning. To these ears, the best Melt Banana tracks have been the ones that utilise more conventional rock structures – the earlier works always struck me as being overly repetitive. Still, despondent fans will be pleased to note that seven out of the eighteen tracks on offer here return to their cathartic noise roots – all lo-fi bursts of electronic noise and over-before-you’ve-caught-your-breath rhythm sections.

This album further reinstates their place as the finest purveyors of Japanese noise-punk. Or is it avant-punk? Who honestly cares – all that really needs to be said about Bambi’s Dilemma is that it’s Melt Banana's finest record to date, and for that, we should all be very excited. Yes, Melt Banana are in fine form.

  • Melt Banana 8 / 10

Good review

And I definitely agree that Melt-Banana are better when they squeeze their craziness into something approaching a recognisable structure.......although a bit of 30-second noise grenadery is always welcome. I'm glad they went for a mix.

This is better than Cell-Scape, too. At least as accessible, with 2 minute songs as opposed to 3-4 minuters.

They need to come and play me these tunes.


I've also preferred

Melt Banana within more conventional song structures, hence Cell Scape is my favourite MB record. I find with some of the shorter tracks that listening to them all can be a bit hard-going, and they can blur into one a bit.

Is this record out yet?


I can't

wait to hear this.


awful

just awful.


wrong

just wrong.

mighty fine record


"avant-punk"

"avant-punk" - Nice.

I've referred to them myself as avant-garde punk in the last few weeks as I tried to explain these guys to friends in preparation for their show last night in Omaha, NE.

They were awesome and fun, and I am enamored with Agata's sounds. He gives you so much to listen to. Nice folks too. The sound quality wasn't too hot though. Anyway, I picked up 'Bambi' and finally have given it a few rotations today (3 so far). F*ing awesome... probably my favorite MxBx to date (haven't heard Cell-Scape and a few others though).

I definitely welcome the directions as much as I like the older style. And hearing both on this disc makes for very good listen (keeps you on your toes). Good head phone music to boot. Agata's the man.

EP