Sundance
Comes Home
My
great-grandfather was the Sundance Kid. He did not die in
Bolivia in 1908 but returned to his family in Utah and died in
1936. I have compiled the information and have written his true
story.
I grew up
hearing tales about my great-grandfather Bill Long being an
outlaw who rode with Butch Cassidy. We knew the name he used
was an alias. He deliberately told the family misleading
information about himself to divert them away from his real
identity-Harry Longabaugh, aka: The Sundance Kid. He claimed he
was Bill McCarty, another outlaw that was killed in a bank
hold-up in 1893, and by doing so he could tell outlaw stories
about himself. He knew he would be safe from the law because
Bill McCarty was dead. The generation that heard these stories
directly from him did not have any reason to doubt him, and they
could not verify the stories, so they believed them.
As a young boy
I listened to these stories and found it fascinating to think I
had an outlaw ancestor. “The Outlaw Trail” by Charles Kelly
(about Butch Cassidy) mentions my grandfather, Jerry Jackson.
When the movie, “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid” was
released, I discovered that Sundance’s name was “Longabaugh.”
Since my great grandfather’s name was Long I thought that was
amazing coincidence. Charles Kelly said they were killed in
Bolivia and that is what the movie implied so I thought that
would be the end of the Bill Long story.
Butch
Cassidy’s sister, Lula Bentenson, wrote a book in which she
stated that Butch and Sundance were not killed in Bolivia.
Butch returned home and visited his family in Circleville, Utah
in 1925. There was a Lula Bentenson/Butch Cassidy article
published in the January 17, 1976 issue of the Deseret News,
which mentioned Bill Long.
When the book
“In Search of Butch Cassidy” by Larry Pointer was published I
read it and believed Pointer has also conclusively shown Butch
Cassidy was not killed in Bolivia but returned home to the
United States. I knew if Butch returned home then Sundance also
returned home, but no one had made the Bill Long/Sundance
connection yet.
In the famous
Fort Worth photograph I noticed the amazing similarity between
Bill Long and Sundance. Could Bill Long be Harry Longabaugh,
aka The Sundance Kid? I had to prove it, one-way or the other.
I acquired public records and collected family stories. All
evidence pointed to Bill Long and Sundance being the same
person. I created a web site to present my evidence for all to
see and evaluate. I was also hoping to meet someone off the
Internet that would show me information to prove or disprove my
theory. Bill Long has descendants and a large extended family
and I was also hoping to meet relatives for the first time and
find out what they knew about Bill Long. The website proved
more successful than I had hoped. I did meet relatives for the
first time and they gave me a lot of new information and
photographs.
In 2007
filmmaker Michael Karr contacted me and proposed that we do a
documentary, which is currently being produced. Further
research led to the exhumation of Bill Long’s remains for DNA
tests and for a scientific examination by Dr. John McCullough of
the University of Utah. Dr. McCullough is a well-known forensic
anthropologist and forensic facial expert. He concluded that we
had found Sundance.
The documentary
and a book of his exciting adventures and romances are forth
coming.
Jerry Nickle
On Dec 12, 2008 the remains
of Bill long were exhumed and taken to the laboratory for DNA
tests. The Deseret News had an article with photographs
published in their Dec 16, 2008 issue.